Flavors of Paradise: Best Places To Eat in Islamorada Florida

Best Restaurants in Islamorada

Discover the exquisite culinary offerings of Islamorada, Florida, with our comprehensive guide to the best places to eat in Islamorada Florida. Indulge in a delightful journey through the diverse flavors and delectable dishes that this tropical paradise has to offer. Immerse yourself in the vibrant culinary scene of Islamorada, where every bite is a true taste of paradise.

Below are the best restaurants in Islamorada that locals and tourists to the area love. They are the best places to eat in Islamorada. Each one is selected for their food quality, customer service and location on the island.

Lorelei Restaurant and Cabana Bar

“The Pulse Of Islamorada”, The Lorelei Restaurant and Cabana Bar features some of the best seafood in the Florida Keys… the perfect place to sit back, order a tall, cool drink and let yourself be enchanted. They have plenty of seating to enjoy breathtaking views of world-famous sunsets. Find a seat for Sunset Celebrations nightly with live entertainment!

Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner including a kid’s menu, delicious food, beach and waterfront dining. Large groups are welcome. The Lorelei is the perfect venue for special events and weddings. Look for the mermaid at Mile Marker 82, Bayside, Islamorada Florida Keys! Come By Land Or Sea! Located in Islamorada at MM 82 waterfront.

This is a local legend for their nightly sunset celebrations.

Pierre’s Restaurant

Located in the heart of Islamorada at mile marker 81.6, Pierre’s Restaurant is set amidst a glorious, palm-lined beach overlooking Florida Bay, with walking paths through tropical flowers.

Guests may enjoy fine dining on the second floor or on the veranda accompanied by Islamorada’s spectacular sunsets and tropical views. The Green Flash Lounge serves guests on the main floor and the downstairs veranda.

Featuring French Fusion cuisine with World influences, Pierre’s was recently noted by Zagat’s as “one of the top all-around dining experiences” in the Florida Keys. At Pierre’s, spectacular dining and extraordinary décor merge in dramatic fashion. This is fine dining in paradise.

Bayside Gourmet

The Bayside Gourmet of Islamorada is a family-owned and operated establishment, priding itself on the most authentic preparations of classic and contemporary cuisine. Their menu and specialty items are made from the freshest ingredients and hand-prepared in their kitchen.

If you do not see something you crave, please ask and we will prepare it for you if at all possible.

Dine indoors or on the patio.
Located at MM 82.7, Bayside, Islamorada.

 Lazy Days Restaurant

Lazy Days Restaurant is situated in the heart of Islamorada, which is part of the Florida Keys. The exact address is 79867 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036 (MM79.9).

Lazy Days is renowned for its seafood offerings and Florida Keys cuisine. The menu typically features a variety of fresh seafood dishes, including locally caught fish, lobster, shrimp, and more. Non-seafood options and a selection of cocktails are also available.

The restaurant offers a casual and relaxed atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating options. Outdoor seating often provides views of the beautiful waters of the Florida Keys.

Some of the popular dishes at Lazy Days include the fresh catch of the day, conch fritters, and, of course, Key Lime pie for dessert.

Given its location in Islamorada, Lazy Days Restaurant is known for providing a great spot to enjoy sunset views over the water.

 Islamorada Fish Company

The Islamorada Fish Company is situated at 81532 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036. The restaurant is known for its seafood-centric menu, offering a variety of dishes featuring fresh catches from the surrounding waters. Seafood options may include fish, shrimp, crab, lobster, and more. Non-seafood items, salads, and sandwiches are also typically available.

The Islamorada Fish Company often provides a casual and laid-back atmosphere, reflecting the relaxed vibe of the Florida Keys. Outdoor seating is available, allowing guests to enjoy the tropical surroundings in a Tiki-like setting.

Given its location in Islamorada, the restaurant may offer waterfront or marina views, providing a scenic backdrop for diners. Islamorada Fish Company is associated with Bass Pro Shops or the World Wide Sportsman store in front of the facility.

Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet

Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet is located at 83413 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036. As the name suggests, the restaurant is known for its seafood buffet. The buffet typically offers a wide variety of fresh seafood options, including fish, shrimp, crab, oysters, and more. Non-seafood items and a selection of desserts may also be part of the buffet.

The restaurant may provide a casual and family-friendly atmosphere. Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet operates on a buffet-style dining concept, allowing patrons to serve themselves from a variety of dishes.

Given its location in Islamorada, the restaurant offers scenic views, and some tables might provide a waterfront or marina setting.

Green Turtle Inn

The Green Turtle Inn is situated at 81219 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036. This historic restaurant has been on the road to Key West for decades. The Green Turtle Inn has a valuable history in the Florida Keys and is considered one of the iconic and historic landmarks in Islamorada. It dates back to the 1940s and has retained its classic Florida Keys charm.

The restaurant is known for its seafood and American cuisine. The menu typically features a variety of seafood dishes, as well as other traditional American fare. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner options are available. The Green Turtle has been one of the best places to eat in Islamorada for decades.

The Green Turtle Inn offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere. The interior may have a retro Florida Keys vibe, and some outdoor seating options are available.

Some popular dishes at the Green Turtle Inn may include fresh catches of the day, lobster, shrimp, and other seafood specialties.

Morada Bay Beach Cafe

Morada Bay Beach Cafe is a popular restaurant located at 81600 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036.

The restaurant is known for its picturesque setting with a beachfront location. It offers stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico, making it a popular spot for enjoying sunsets.

Morada Bay Beach Cafe features a diverse menu with a focus on fresh seafood and tropical flavors. The menu includes a variety of dishes ranging from seafood specialties to salads, sandwiches, and more.

The ambiance is relaxed and tropical, creating a laid-back and enjoyable dining experience. Outdoor seating is available, allowing patrons to dine with views of the water.

Morada Bay Beach Cafe often hosts live music events, enhancing the overall dining experience with entertainment. The restaurant may host special events, private parties, and weddings, taking advantage of its scenic location for celebrations.

In addition to the restaurant, Morada Bay features a beachfront bar where guests can enjoy tropical drinks and cocktails.

Chef Michael’s

Chef Michael’s in Islamorada is a fine dining establishment consistently ranking high among the best restaurants in the Florida Keys. It is located at 81671 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036. The restaurant boasts an elegant yet relaxed atmosphere, perfect for a special occasion or a refined culinary experience. Expect white tablecloths, polished wooden accents, and attentive service.

Chef Michael’s menu celebrates the bounty of the Florida Keys, featuring fresh seafood as the star attraction. Think locally caught fish prepared in various ways, from simply grilled to dressed with creative sauces and paired with complementary sides. Their menu also includes other high-quality meat and vegetarian options.

The menu changes seasonally to ensure the freshest ingredients are always used. So, expect a delightful surprise each visit, showcasing the current culinary inspirations of Chef Michael. Some of their most popular dishes include the blackened lionfish, the ambassador grouper with crabmeat and shiitake mushrooms, and the grilled filet mignon with smoky bacon and gorgonzola cream sauce. They also have a delicious selection of appetizers, salads, and desserts.

Complement your meal with a selection from their award-winning wine list, boasting an impressive variety of international and domestic wines. The knowledgeable staff can help you find the perfect pairing for your chosen dishes.

Overall, Chef Michael’s offers a refined dining experience in Islamorada, showcasing fresh seafood, an elegant atmosphere, and impeccable service. While it’s a pricier option, it’s a fantastic choice for a special occasion or a truly memorable culinary journey.

Marker 88

Marker 88 is a local favorite restaurant and Tiki Bar located aptly at 88000 Overseas Highway. (MM88)

Located in Plantation Key, in the Village of Islamorada, Florida, Marker 88 has been serving guests since 1967.

If you are traveling through the Keys, this is a well-known spot for fresh seafood, hand-crafted cocktails and a great view of the bay.

At sunset, Marker 88 comes alive as people prepare for another colorful end to the day. If you like great views, exceptional food and a tropical vibe, Marker 88 is one of the best places to eat in Islamorada.

Marker 88 is also listed as one of the best tiki bars in Florida.

Mangrove Mike’s

Mangrove Mike’s is one of the premier breakfast restaurants in the Florida Keys. In 2021 the owner died and the staff and heirs have continued a legacy of great food.

The colorful and playful decorations hide the fact they know how a good breakfast should be served.

Mangrove Miles is located at 82200 Overseas Hwy MM 82, Islamorada, FL 33036 and is generally a stop on the way to Key West for us.

Shrimp Shack 

The Shrimp Shack is located at 81901 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL ! This vibrant spot promises a laid-back island atmosphere with buckets of fresh seafood and tropical island vibes. Imagine picnic tables under colorful umbrellas, live music on the breeze, and friendly staff ready to dish up your next beachy bite.

Their claim to fame is, as the name suggests, the shrimp – think golden fried, peel-and-eat, scampi, and even key lime shrimp tacos. But you can also find classics like grouper sandwiches, crab cakes, and juicy burgers. It’s all casual, messy, and oh-so-satisfying, perfect for a fun lunch or a relaxed dinner after a day by the water.

So grab a cold beer, soak up the island sun, and dive into the seafood bounty at The Shrimp Shack – it’s a taste of Islamorada’s carefree spirit with every bite!

More Top Restaurants in Islamorada

• Bob’s Bunz Islamorada Restaurant & Bakery

81620 Overseas Highway Islamorada FL 33036

85361 Overseas Highway Islamorada FL

80499 Overseas Highway Islamorada FL 33036

84500 Overseas Highway Islamorada FL 33036

Chinese and Thai takeout 82685 Overseas Highway Islamorada FL

Mile Marker 80 Inside Islander Bayside Resort Islamorada FL

Mile Marker 87.7 Islamorada FL

(305) 453-6377

Mile marker 83.5, bayside Overseas Highway Islamorada FL 33036

82245 Overseas Highway MM 82 Oceanside Islamorada FL

(305) 396-7481

Final Thoughts on the Best Places to Eat in Islamorada Florida

In conclusion, Islamorada offers a culinary experience that is unparalleled. From the fresh seafood delicacies at The Green Turtle Inn to the delectable Caribbean-inspired dishes at Pierre’s Restaurant, there is no shortage of gastronomic delights. Whether you’re a seafood lover or seeking a taste of international flavors, Islamorada’s diverse dining scene will leave you satisfied and yearning for more.

Islamorada is an island in the Florida Keys that represents the best of the tropical vibe throughout the islands. The best places to eat in Islamorada may not have anything to do with food. It could be the views, the entertainment or the sunset. Everything contributes to a meal in paradise.

You May Also Like….

133 Mile Markers in the Florida Keys

Manatees in the Florida Keys

Must Have Florida Travel Guide

.